3 hands at 2/5 against 100% VPIP Whale

So you were bluffing a calling station.

You should've probably picked up on that way way before the first hand.

The last hand it's easy fold unless you know for sure that she overvalues hands.

you play too loose pre, cbet too much, and bluff when you dont rep anything.

Hand 1 is fine but I think you can give up turn. If there wasn't a flush completing turn and if you were shallower I would probably jam for value to get called by worse Ax or air. But 200bb eff I think you threw too much into this pot

Hand 2 I would iso the whale pre you want to go heads up vs her as frequently as possible.

Hand 3 I read results so I'm already biased and usually prefer to get the results later. I prefer to check back K high flush draws on a paired board multiway flop. But after that I think you played fine

Also ignore these comments above lol I think overall your strategy vs a whale fish is smart and variance definitely played a role in the bad outcomes. Iso with a slightly wider range that performs well post flop, and get it in with slightly lighter value than usual.

Agree with B00m that you should ignore the comments. There is nothing in the hands you posted that suggests she is a calling station, and against the average fish you should be bluffing a lot simply because they are overfolding almost everywhere.

Hand 1: Flop and turn are wp, but I would jam the river.

Hand 2: I would iso pre, but apart from that it's also wp.

Hand 3: I would probably fold the river but it's close.

To the guys saying OP shouldn't bluff her: she is playing close to 100% of hands preflop, do you really think she'll be able to defend enough of that range to stop OP's bluffs from being profitable?

Hand #3 is a fold since even fish know a paired board is bad for a flush.

Hand #2 is WP. But it’s possible isoing preflop is better depending on the opponents behind you.

Hand #1 is a triple barrel if she is as wide as you say. Against a normal fish it is a give up OTT.

Variance is tough, especially live when you don’t see many hands.

Yes because her leak isn't she folds too often. You can not successfully multi--barrel bluff a calling station. You can bluff but once called unless you are betting for value you are handing her money.

This is not correct.

Your strategy of bluffing once is exploiting yourself because the 100 VPIP fish will call flops/turns more than theory to see if she hits her hand.

You should be triple barrel bluffing a 100 VPIP fish more than regular fish/regular players not less.

Absent the hand histories you have an argument but facts trump theory. This fish will call down with low pairs, do a small c-bet to try to take pots, and let you hang yourself when she flops big. We obviously did not get to see every hand she played but every hand we were shown she calls down once she calls once. She definitely plays too many hands but in every hand we saw she is not a random call every hand fish post flop. And her being up as much as she was suggests thinking of her as a fool post flop is an expensive mistake.

I don't see anything that seems bad, though it depends on her tendencies, obviously.

I disagree with the turn on hand 1. I feel that we are value betting and also trying to buy a cheap river. This type of player will often let you dictate the action, so I would bet quite a bit smaller. Maybe just do 80 again, maybe 100. She isn't folding a queen and might not fold any pair. So we want some value from unpaired hands and a chance to suck out against pairs at a reasonable price.

Hand 2 I would generally isso with 56s. However, if people are 3! when they know you are isoing wide, then it is OK to limp call so you get to play the pot with her. You could consider blasting the turn obviously, but call is OK. River bluff is OK.

Hand 3: Ugly. I pretty much agree with your thought process, but I would try to get good reads on V, as I'm sure you did. There might be cases where you could find a fold here. Some players are whales who just DGAF about the money, but they do understand handstrengths and aren't nec. totally idiotic post flop or in spots like this. Others are just super passive, playing bingo and won't be looking to raise unless they have a sure winner. But there are some who rarely play poker and might just think "flush!" You said she seemed possibly intoxicated so I can't fault you for calling.

Grunch

Hand 1 Flop bet is fine because we have great equity vs. her range but I give up OTT on a card which doesn't improve us.

Hand 2 I fold river.

Hand 3 Raise for value is probably good, calling her jam is not good.

My strat against this sort of V would be to use lots of smaller bets when we're bluffing or have thin value, under-bluff / over-fold when she shows aggression, and go for max value when we can cooler her, knowing she has a hard time folding.

Trying to make her fold ATC while we're holding napkins and over-playing our marginal relative value hands is just torching.

Also helpful to delay gratification with delayed aggression. Like, H1, I would just check flop and turn, see what she does, and consider raising turn or river. H2 I'd iso pre, check back flop, raise turn, and probably barrel river. H3 I might not even play pre, but if we do, I think we just need to barrel turn and river, then consider folding when she raises. If she donks river, I'd be careful about raising, when we've shown nothing but strength.