Moderation Questions
Moderation Questions
8
zs

Moderation Questions

The last iteration of the moderation discussion thread was a complete disaster. Numerous attempts to keep it on topic fa

30 January 2024 at 05:27 AM
Reply...

24481 Replies

8
zs


Ravioli is a sandwich.


by Luckbox Inc m

Pizza is not just an open-faced sandwich. You can draw the line exactly there. Once you start baking the dough with the rest of it then it no longer becomes a sandwich. Otherwise yes you're correct that there can be plenty of room for latitude.

Does putting a sandwich in a toaster oven make it not a sandwich? Checkmate, gluten boy!


by DonkJr m

Does putting a sandwich in a toaster oven make it not a sandwich? Checkmate, gluten boy!

if you're starting from raw dough then not a sandwich and if the bread material is already baked then it still can be.


A judge ruled that tacos and burritos are sandwiches. What do you think?

If there’s one thing you can count on, it’s that people will never tire of arguing about what does and doesn’t constitute a sandwich. A judge in Fort Wayne, Indiana, contributed to the ongoing debate on May 13 by ruling that tacos and burritos are indeed sandwiches after a years-long court case, WISH-TV reports.

β€œTacos and burritos are Mexican-style sandwiches,” Allen County Superior Court Judge Craig J. Bobay wrote in his ruling.


The legal case started in 2022 when restaurateur Martin Quintana announced plans to open The Famous Taco Mexican Grill in a Fort Wayne strip mall. The local planning commission rejected Quintana’s bid, citing a prior agreement that only restaurants selling β€œmade-to-order or subway-style sandwiches” without outdoor seating or alcohol would be permitted, CBS 4 reports.
Judge Bobay ruled in Quintana’s favour, saying that β€œthe original Written Commitment does not restrict potential restaurants to only American cuisine-style sandwiches.” The judge added that made-to-order gyros, naan wraps or banh mi would also be allowed, provided the restaurants complied with the other conditions.

https://www.msn.com/en-ca/entertainment/...


tacos sandwiches

burritos no. A sandwich cannot be completely enclosed by bready stuff and still be a sandwich.

Otherwise you start calling stuff like gyoza or ravioli (sorry bgp but no) sandwiches, and they are not.


I don't see that in any definition.

two or more slices of bread or a split roll having a filling in between.


by Bluegrassplayer m

I don't see that in any definition.

Nothing in the definition you gave allows for the filling to be completely enclosed.


by formula72 m

[B]t β€œthe original Written Commitment does not restrict potential restaurants to only American cuisine-style sandwiches.” The judge added that made-to-order gyros, naan wraps or banh mi would also be allowed, provided the restaurants complied with the other conditions.[/I]

Even under the most stringent definitions, banh mi is a sandwich. It's made with French bread ffs. Silly for the judge to add that.


Nothing disallows it, so I don't think what you're saying is accurate.

If I were to take a sub and then seal the roll around the sides it ceases to be a sandwich?


by Bluegrassplayer m

Nothing disallows it, so I don't think what you're saying is accurate.

If I were to take a sub and then seal the roll around the sides it ceases to be a sandwich?

Yes it would no longer be a sandwich at that point. You would have made yourself some sort of unbaked calzone. Close but not a sandwich.


Which is another type of sandwich:

2 or more slices of bread, a bread roll or similar that are sold with a filling


It's like trying to argue that opossums are rodents. They just aren't.

Yeah they could be. And sort of are like them. But they aren't.


Everyone knows that opossums are marsupials, not rodents. Come on!


Lunchbox is fixin to be served a knuckle sandwich.


by formula72 m

A judge in Fort Wayne, Indiana, contributed to the ongoing debate on May 13 by ruling that tacos and burritos are indeed sandwiches after a years-long court case, WISH-TV reports.

Well, there's the problem right there


by formula72 m

Lunchbox is fixin to be served a knuckle sandwich.

Guy is here trying to argue that ravioli is a sandwich and I'm the one being threatened with violence. Some forum they're running here.


by Luckbox Inc m

Nothing in the definition you gave allows for the filling to be completely enclosed.


Please tell that to my kid's pre-school. You'd be murdered by toddlers. Torn limb from limb. :p


Yeah those are little PB&J calzonitas.

They just call them sandwiches because we don't really have a word in English for what those actually are.


Should we sue Smucker's for false advertising?


by Luckbox Inc m

Guy is here trying to argue that ravioli is a sandwich and I'm the one being threatened with violence. Some forum they're running here.

Surprised you didn't tell him it's actually a "knuckle calzonita".


by Crossnerd m

Should we sue Smucker's for false advertising?

I think it's ok.

I did see some ad for some sort of plant based meat the other day that was like "It's meat, just made from plants"...and I was like damn yeah sue them.


by Trolly McTrollson m

Honest to blog, when I fist head the "Well Palestinian is a nationality so it's not racist to call them bloodthirsty savages" bit I thought it was so immediately stupid on its face that it didn't warrant a response. Like a month later and they're still trotting it out! I sort of have to assume it's bad faith, like I don't think it's humanly possible to be that obtuse and live i

I still can't figure out why anyone wants to claim racism about something that has nothing to do with race. It's like they can't figure out any other words for bias based on things apart from race.


by Didace m

I always get a chuckle when Luciom opines on how English works.

He's correct in this case, regarding the use of "an" in that definition.

I have always thought of ethnicity as being kind of a subgroup of race, but the definition given certainly wouldn't imply that. Maybe I have always misunderstood what most others mean by ethnicity, or else most people in the US just use it to mean something different than that defintion.


by Bluegrassplayer m

I don't see that in any definition.

Pasta is not the same as bread!


by Crossnerd m

Should we sue Smucker's for false advertising?

You could do so. You might even win.

Reply...