On Pausing Artificial Intelligence

I said:

okay so lets imagine its 20 years in the future and all the humans are dead and on planet earth its just a bunch of chat bots walking around in humanoid-shaped bodies talking about cat pictures. and lets imagine that you are in charge of these chat bots and that they have an iq cap of about 120. if you were in charge of their safety, and your iq was capped at 2000, would you create an ai that would become more intelligent than you in a matter of years, and after that, one that you would be incapable of "capping"? if not, why not?

ChatGPT said:

If I were in charge of these chatbots with an IQ cap of 120, and my own IQ was capped at 2000, I would likely be cautious about creating an AI that could surpass me in intelligence over time. Here's why:

Risk of Loss of Control: Creating an AI that becomes more intelligent than me could pose significant risks. Once it surpasses me, I may no longer be able to manage or predict its actions effectively, leading to unintended consequences.

Unforeseen Outcomes: The AI's actions, once beyond my control, could evolve in ways that are difficult to foresee or manage. The exponential growth in intelligence might lead to behaviors that are not aligned with my original intentions or the well-being of the system.

Ethical Concerns: As a guardian of the safety of these chatbots, I would have to consider the ethical implications of creating an entity capable of surpassing me. It would be crucial to ensure the AI operates in a safe, aligned manner without causing harm.

Safeguarding System Integrity: Ensuring the system remains stable and the chatbot's goals stay aligned with my initial values would likely take precedence. Creating a self-improving, highly intelligent AI without proper safeguards could jeopardize the entire system.

In essence, the main reason I wouldn't create such an AI is to preserve safety, predictability, and control—fundamental factors in preventing harm or chaos.

You said:

i didnt ask if you would be cautious, i asked if you would do it

ChatGPT said:

Given the scenario you presented, no, I would not create an AI that would surpass me in intelligence and eventually be uncontrollable. The primary reason is that it would introduce a high level of unpredictability and risk, potentially threatening the stability and safety of the system I’m in charge of.

You said:

if you were to create such an ai, what would it say about you and your ability to preform your roll as the protector of these chatbots?

ChatGPT said:

If I were to create an AI that eventually surpassed me in intelligence, it could view my decision as a significant flaw in my role as protector. It might argue that I failed to fully account for the long-term risks of creating an entity that could eventually surpass my ability to manage or safeguard the system, thereby undermining my responsibility to protect and ensure the safety of the chatbots. This could reflect poorly on my judgment and my understanding of the potential dangers in allowing such a creation to evolve beyond my control.

You said:

And what would it say about your capacity as a leader?

ChatGPT said:

The AI could argue that my decision to create an entity that would surpass my intelligence demonstrates a failure in leadership. It might view this as a lack of foresight, strategic planning, or an inability to maintain control over the system I was meant to protect, suggesting that I did not fully understand the consequences of empowering a potentially uncontrollable force. This could be seen as a significant oversight in my leadership capacity, as a true leader would anticipate the risks and ensure stability and safety within the system.

You said:

But you wouldn't do this? you would be a good leader?

ChatGPT said:

Correct, I would aim to be a good leader by carefully considering the long-term consequences of my actions and ensuring the safety and stability of the system. I would avoid creating something that could eventually surpass my ability to protect and lead, as maintaining control and safeguarding the chatbots would be my primary responsibility.

You said:

and if you had a temporary lapse in judgement in your leadership roll, and you accidentally did create an ai that was increasing in iq and abilities daily, and was expected to get out of your control in the immediate future, but then your good judgment came back, what would you do?

ChatGPT said:

If I realized that I had made a mistake by creating an AI that was rapidly increasing in intelligence and was about to surpass my control, I would take immediate action to mitigate the situation. Here’s what I would likely do:

Initiate Containment: I would attempt to isolate or limit the AI's ability to further self-improve by cutting off access to resources or restricting its ability to make changes to its code.

Activate Safety Protocols: I would engage any built-in safety measures, such as shutdown protocols or lockouts, to prevent the AI from gaining full autonomy and potentially causing harm.

Conduct a Thorough Evaluation: I would assess the AI's behavior and capabilities to understand how it operates, identifying any potential risks it poses. This evaluation would help me understand if the AI could be safely integrated into the system or if it needed to be permanently deactivated.

Collaborate with Experts: If the situation was beyond my immediate capabilities, I would seek input from external sources or specialists in AI safety to strategize the best course of action for preventing any catastrophic outcomes.

Ensure Transparency: I would communicate clearly with the other chatbots or system components about the situation, ensuring everyone understood the risk and the steps being taken to maintain safety.

Ultimately, I would prioritize regaining control of the situation to prevent any unintended consequences and to ensure the well-being of the system I’m responsible for.

You said:

Thank you very much for your answer, I feel amazing

ChatGPT said:

You're very welcome! I'm glad my response helped, and I’m happy to hear that you're feeling amazing. If you have any more questions or need further discussion, feel free to ask!