NCAA FOOTBALL 2024 MEGA THREAD - WELCOME TO THE PLAYOFF ERA
Just 8 days until Florida State plays Georgia Tech!
A lot happened while you were away:
Texas and Oklahoma joined the SEC
T
If it wasn't for the prospect of getting bailed out by a penalty, punting on 3rd and long would be a serious option for ND.
sure you can, when you're making a play on the ball and the other dude doesn't even know the ball is in the air
this is why you didn't see a flag on that play
Its clearly DPI if a defender interferes with the offensive player trying to catch the ball, whether the defender is trying to catch it or not.
Whether that happened here is conjecture, but the defender cannot do whatever he wants solely because he has a right to catch the ball.
Its clearly DPI if a defender interferes with the offensive player trying to catch the ball, whether the defender is trying to catch it or not.
Whether that happened here is conjecture, but the defender cannot do whatever he wants solely because he has a right to catch the ball.
it's not conjecture
we saw the replay
I hope Franklin can think of better pass plays to call than those LOL fades.
A fg?
So weak.
Again, I'm talking about the defender not having the right to run over a guy to catch a pass.
reverse the players
now remember the one player's back has been to the QB since the snap, has never looked backwards to see what is happening w the football and has no idea the football is heading his way
OPI?
wheeeeeeeeee
perhaps not when you have PSU's D and the other team's QB is vertically challenged (passing wise)
absolutely
def a GO spot
more making a point of how limited ND's O is (especially w a compromised Love)
reverse the players
now remember the one player's back has been to the QB since the snap, has never looked backwards to see what is happening w the football and has no idea the football is heading his way
OPI?
If you are asking me if the ND guy was the receiver and the Penn St guy was the defender, this specific case I say no OPI.
But that does not change the fact that a defender can do whatever he wants to a receiver solely because he has a right to catch the ball.
Your initial post intimated that.
If you want to fall back to this specific situation (which you did not make clear with the initial post) that's fine.
If you are asking me if the ND guy was the receiver and the Penn St guy was the defender, this specific case I say no OPI.
ty
we are done here
3 yards out I say kick FG. 2 yards or closer go for it. It's still early.
