“Haha all in…?” muck.

Hi all,

Playing 1/2 plo and I’m not really paying attention to the action, I have a completely garbage hand and this dude standing behind me railing comes over and I show him my hand to show him how bad it is and jokingly say to him “all in” and chuckle. I then quickly muck but the cards are retrievable. The stuck gambler who raised wants my “bet” to be committing and calls the floor over.

The floor says my all in bet stands and makes me put in a pot sized raise ($175). Was this outcome fair even though I was obviously joking and “all in” isn’t even a legal bet?

Thanks,
DT