Moderation Questions
Moderation Questions
8
zs

Moderation Questions

The last iteration of the moderation discussion thread was a complete disaster. Numerous attempts to keep it on topic fa

30 January 2024 at 05:27 AM
Reply...

24457 Replies

8
zs


by 5 south m

Watched that Lex Friedman debate with Finkelstein, etc... thought it was good mainly because everyone behaved civilized. I already knew basically all the arguments from both sides because I follow the thread in the forum. Losing the Zionist voices from the thread pretty much ruins it and what Mets said I doubt insulted anyone more than Victor calling people genocide lovers.From

I don't think you get it. Saying Palestinian parents are having children out of some patriotic duty is one of the worst things anyone could say. 2 weeks? He got off easy.


by Luckbox Inc m

I don't think you get it. Saying Palestinian parents are having children out of some patriotic duty is one of the worst things anyone could say. 2 weeks? He got off easy.

Maybe I don't get it but I guess I'm off when I don't think of Mets as some far right extremist either. So if that is something that a decent percent of Zionists think, let's hear it, not ban them.


by 5 south m

Maybe I don't get it but I guess I'm off when I don't think of Mets as some far right extremist either. So if that is something that a decent percent of Zionists think, let's hear it, not ban them.

OK sure. But he violated a direct order from Browser.


by Luckbox Inc m

OK sure. But he violated a direct order from Browser.

Well I don't know his previous violations but have to think they're pretty minimal, so I'd say it's a bit excessive. Anyways, I'm sure Browser will make a fair decision when he clears his head.


by Luckbox Inc m

OK sure. But he violated a direct order from Browser.

Mets ignored the order. We follow orders or people die, son.


by 5 south m

Maybe I don't get it but I guess I'm off when I don't think of Mets as some far right extremist either. So if that is something that a decent percent of Zionists think, let's hear it, not ban them.

ofc hes an extremist. he supports bombing and starving millions of people to steal their land.


by Victor m

ofc hes an extremist. he supports bombing and starving millions of people to steal their land.

Your hero Stalin would approve, especially of the starving part.


by d2_e4 m

Your hero Stalin would approve, especially of the starving part.

so would your boy Churchill and every American president in the 1800s.


by Victor m

so would your boy Churchill and every American president in the 1800s.

Ah, the highly intellectual and factually grounded "no u" rejoinder. Suits you.


by d2_e4 m

Ah, the highly intellectual and factually grounded "no u" rejoinder. Suits you.

bruv, this you?



by Victor m

bruv, this you?

Have you finally lost the last marble you had left?


Oh so that wasn't a "no, u rejoinder" bc reasons.


by Victor m

ofc hes an extremist. he supports bombing and starving millions of people to steal their land.

There is a really nice Caitlyn Johnstone article on this subject Centrists are violet extremists


by Victor m

Oh so that wasn't a "no, u rejoinder" bc reasons.

For the benefit of the hard of thinking, the "no u" part is the laughable assertion that the west was just as bad or worse than Stalin. Not "no u d2".


by d2_e4 m

For the benefit of the hard of thinking, the "no u" part is the laughable assertion that the west was just as bad or worse than Stalin. Not "no u d2".

I have to imagine the West's body count by this point far exceeds what Stalin did.


they blame Stalin for all the Nazi deaths in WW2. Victims of Communism.


by Luckbox Inc m

I have to imagine the West's body count by this point far exceeds what Stalin did.

by Victor m

they blame Stalin for all the Nazi deaths in WW2. Victims of Communism.

Lol. Run along to BBV chaps, the adults are discussing politics here.


by d2_e4 m

Lol. Run along to BBV chaps, the adults are discussing politics here.

So you think Stalin's body count is higher or you dismiss the idea that body count is the way to accurately measure how bad a regime is?


by Victor m

ofc hes an extremist. he supports bombing and starving millions of people to steal their land.

By today's definition he's center right.


by Luckbox Inc m

So you think Stalin's body count is higher or you dismiss the idea that body count is the way to accurately measure how bad a regime is?

"Body count" is a meaningless measure without context, such as time frame and reasons for the bodies.

Are you going to compare a soldier in active combat to a serial killer by body count? The point is so puerile as not to be worth addressing.

By the measure innocent people per unit time murdered for potical reasons, worked to death as slaves, imprisoned in abject conditions, starved to death, or otherwise genocided, Stalin doesn't have much competition. Just Hitler, Pol Pot, Mao, and the North Koreans, really.


I believe it was Stalin himself who came up with the phrase "you kill a few people, it's murder. You kill a few million, it's a statistic." It's widely attributed to him, anyway.


by d2_e4 m

I believe it was Stalin himself who came up with the phrase "you kill a few people, it's murder. You kill a few million, it's a statistic." It's widely attributed to him, anyway.

Yeah but afaik there's no actual proof he said this and if he did he's thought to be quoting a German writer's 1932 essay

https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Politics/2...

There's no proof that Stalin ever said this, but even if he did, he would likely have been quoting a 1932 essay on French humor by the German journalist, satirist, and pacifist Kurt Tucholsky.

Much like Rousseau did with his "great princess," Tucholsky quotes a fictional diplomat from the French Ministry of Foreign affairs, speaking on the horrors of war.

"The war?" says Tucholsky's diplomat, "I cannot find it to be so bad! The death of one man: this is a catastrophe. Hundreds of thousands of deaths: that is a statistic!"




by Victor m

given our conversation about the Hamas charter, I dont think you are really able to reliably relay information or decipher it.

Or it could be that your claim was simply just y'know bull$hit.


Stop this derail please. Take it to the appropriate thread.

Reply...