Moderation Questions
Moderation Questions
8
zs

Moderation Questions

The last iteration of the moderation discussion thread was a complete disaster. Numerous attempts to keep it on topic fa

30 January 2024 at 05:27 AM
Reply...

24453 Replies

8
zs


by jalfrezi m

If you must cite mad Freddy at least spell his name correctly.

Nietzsche!!!

Hope you're happy now, jalfreeze!

πŸ˜€


by jalfrezi m

That’s not what Darwin meant by β€œfittest”.

Did Darwin even use the phrase "survival of the fittest?"


Yes, in the fifth edition of On The Origin Of Species.

He wasn’t describing insects going to the gym.


by jalfrezi m

Yes, in the fifth edition of On The Origin Of Species.

He wasn’t describing insects going to the gym.

πŸ˜€

Over 30 years ago I wrote a paper (which was never published) called, "Origin of the Specious." In it, I discussed the origin of Evolutionism and how it predated Darwin by over 2,000 years.


Darwin didn’t invent evolution dude, he discovered it.


by jalfrezi m

Darwin didn’t invent evolution dude, he discovered it.

I never said Darwin invented evolution, dude.

He also didn't discover evolution, dude.

Evolutionism dates back to ancient Greek philosophy, dude.


Fun Factoid:

Charles Darwin's college degree was in Theology.


by geezerchess m

Natural Selection is real.

But even within natural selection, cats have kittens and dogs have puppies.

What is also real is that we are made in the Image of God, which gives us a moral compass.

So obviously you don't think it's fine for people to die of COVID even thought you accept that natural selection is real. Obviously that kind of misanthropy is a non-sequitur.


by Luckbox Inc m

I didn't deliberately give COVID to anyone.

I hate this kind of thinking (not only on this topic but overall). It's not enough to not "mean to" do something. Most of the time there are things you need to "mean not to" do. In other words, actively try to not have something happen. "I didn't mean to drive my car into those people in the crosswalk but I was checking my messages" is not a good excuse. Actions have consequences.


by Crossnerd m

I stopped speaking to my father

this makes me really sad, i hope you can take some time to swallow injustice and mend the void


by Trolly McTrollson m

So obviously you don't think it's fine for people to die of COVID even thought you accept that natural selection is real. Obviously that kind of misanthropy is a non-sequitur.

I think folks dying of COVID is terrible. However, within Evolution Philosophy (which I obviously reject) folks dying of COVID isn't inherently problematic.


by geezerchess m

I think folks dying of COVID is terrible.

So do the folks who accept mainstream science on evolution, so whatever you were implying is rather dishonest.


by Trolly McTrollson m

So do the folks who accept mainstream science on evolution, so whatever you were implying is rather dishonest.

I never said folks who accept mainstream science are happy with folks dying of COVID.

I specifically said (maybe in another thread) that most folks do have compassion for others: the reason being that we all are made in the Image of God and thereby have a conscience.


by geezerchess m

I think folks dying of COVID is terrible. However, within Evolution Philosophy (which I obviously reject) folks dying of COVID isn't inherently problematic.

This is pretty ****ing dumb, even by your standards, and that's some achievement.


by d2_e4 m

This is pretty ****ing dumb, even by your standards, and that's some achievement.

Thank you! I accept any and all accolades!!


by geezerchess m

I think folks dying of COVID is terrible. However, within Evolution Philosophy (which I obviously reject) folks dying of COVID isn't inherently problematic.

you are conflating social darwinism with considering the theory of evolution correct to explain what happens.

it's the social darwinists who won't find it particularly problematic if the weak and frail die.


by Luciom m

you are conflating social darwinism with considering the theory of evolution correct to explain what happens.

it's the social darwinists who won't find it particularly problematic if the weak and frail die.

That's a fair point.

Having said that, Social Darwinism is a natural (so-to-speak) consequence of Evolution Philosophy.


by geezerchess m

I never said folks who accept mainstream science are happy with folks dying of COVID.

I specifically said (maybe in another thread) that most folks do have compassion for others: the reason being that we all are made in the Image of God and thereby have a conscience.

A post I made in this thread just yesterday:

https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/showp...

Natural Selection is real.

But even within natural selection, cats have kittens and dogs have puppies.

What is also real is that we are made in the Image of God, which gives us a moral compass.


by geezerchess m

But even within natural selection, cats have kittens and dogs have puppies.

What is the purpose of this line?


by geezerchess m

A post I made in this thread just yesterday:

https://forumserver.twoplustwo.com/showp...

Natural Selection is real.

But even within natural selection, cats have kittens and dogs have puppies.

What is also real is that we are made in the Image of God, which gives us a moral compass.

So God is a white black brown Chinese trans hermaphrodite? 😡

by Gorgonian m

What is the purpose of this line?

It means men are men and woman are woman and that's all there is to it. Checkmate.


by corpus vile m

So God is a white black brown Chinese trans hermaphrodite? 😡

It means men are men and woman are woman and that's all there is to it. Checkmate.

You guys have to be doing this **** on purpose now.


by geezerchess m

πŸ˜€

Over 30 years ago I wrote a paper (which was never published) called, "Origin of the Specious." In it, I discussed the origin of Evolutionism and how it predated Darwin by over 2,000 years.

No one before Darwin and Wallace had worked out the mechanism, that is, the common descent of all organisms and the practical favouring of random mutations.


by geezerchess m

πŸ˜€

Over 30 years ago I wrote a paper (which was never published) called, "Origin of the Specious." In it, I discussed the origin of Evolutionism and how it predated Darwin by over 2,000 years.

Not bad. Not quite Sense and Sensibilia by JL Austin but I hope the book I never wrote had such a good title.


by Gorgonian m

What is the purpose of this line?

I'm saying Natural Selection doesn't not necessarily entail Macro-Evolution.

Some folks believe that Creationists deny the existence of Natural Selection.


by d2_e4 m

You guys have to be doing this **** on purpose now.

I wanted to see if you'd pick up on it. πŸ˜ƒ

Reply...