New Draft Idea: Fake Bands/Musicians From Movies/TV

New Draft Idea: Fake Bands/Musicians From Movies/TV

Haven't had a good draft in awhile...so let's have one where we draft your favorite bands and/or musicians from the worl

23 May 2025 at 02:24 AM
Reply...

229 Replies


Earlier posts are available on our legacy forum HERE

Round 10
5 Neat Guys
- SCTV

When you think of the greatest vocal harmonizers of the 50's these guys better be on the tip of tounge! SCTV is alway hilarious and all of these guys are all comedic royalty. Lots of untapped potential from the sketch shows that didn't go in this draft.

Final Draft:
Otis Day and the Knights
Sweet Sue and Her Society Syncopaters
The Barden Bellas
Mitch and Mickey
Buddy Love
Jack Malik
Crucial Taunt
The Fabulous Baker Boys
Jeffster
5 Neat Guys


Great draft guys! And thanks to Dom for thinking of it and putting it together! These things are always fun and intriguing.


by mrbaseball

Great draft guys! And thanks to Dom for thinking of it and putting it together! These things are always fun and intriguing.

Yep! This actually is an interesting one with all the grey areas; I’m sorry if someone got offended during those discussions.

I’m going to end in a really grey area; in fact pitch black evil to go with the vampires & Stegman from Class of 1984: I’m picking the cursed harmonica from Once Upon A Time In The West, for the Acid Queen to play during live performances of Midnight Rambler.


https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=qwb3P0fuM1...







Okay, I'm going for a post-modern, Hall of Mirrors trick here. I suppose this one might not be exactly in keeping with the theme but let me know.

Ever hear of the actors Elan Ben Ali and Tijan Njie? No. Me either. But they play two singers who were fakes themselves.

I think you've all caught on by now.

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk


My undrafted list
Cricket Blake (Connie Stevens) - Hawian Eye
The Rocker (movie) either band!
Treme - almost any character!
SNL - too many to mention!
Murph and the Magic Tones - Blues Brothers
The Lone Rangers - Airheads
Wyld Stallions - Bill and Ted
Mozart in the Jungle
A Late Quartet
Walter (Nick Cage) - Peggy Sue Got Married
Deniro and or Minelli - New York New York
Practically any show business based musical (White Christmas, Singing in the Rain, The Music Man etc.)
Ritchie, Ralph and Potsie - Happy Days
Lisa Simpson - Simpsons
Bleedin Gums Murphy - Simpsons
Jeff Bridges - Craazy Heart


by mrbaseball

My undrafted listCricket Blake (Connie Stevens) - Hawian EyeThe Rocker (movie) either band!Treme - almost any character!SNL - too many to mention!Murph and the Magic Tones - Blues BrothersThe Lone Rangers - AirheadsWyld Stallions - Bill and TedMozart in the JungleA Late QuartetWalter (Nick Cage) - Peggy Sue Got MarriedDeniro and or Minelli - New York New YorkPractically any sho




We should all be ashamed, especially me. Definitely the biggest oversight in the draft.

LOL having her so low in the spaghetti against the wall though. I’m definitely filing a protest. 😉


Final picks

AVOIDANCE RECORDS
“Avoid us, and avoid your chance for a REALLY memorable night!”

Sinners Vampire Band
Lazarus from Black Snake Moan
Peanuts Gang
Jessica Rabbit
Duck v Duck
Andrew & Bassist (JVC) from Whiplash
Daniel from Collateral
Peter Stegman from Class Of 1984
The Acid Queen
The Cursed Harmonica from OUATITW

UDFAs
Fflewddur Fflam from The Black Cauldron
Alligator Dixieland Band
Marty McFly & The Starlighters feat. Marvin Berry
(Lisa Simpson protest pending)

STAFF
Prof. Fletcher - Producer/Manager/Emcee
Mr. Norris - Stage Manager/Music Coach/Chaperone
Del Griffith - Transportation/Merchandise

CREW
Roger Rabbit
Fat Teenaged Michael J. Fox
Barely Visible Teenaged Keanu Reeves


by BullyEyelash

Being notified the Alligators are ineligible due to being park attractions not film characters, so I’m replacing them with

Spoiler
Show


I was going to pick the Treblemakers, but I thought, Why look for treble?

Better planning would have gotten the Swanky Modes from Tapeheads in as an early pick.

I leave you with The Kitauji High School Music Club from Sound Euphonium. It would have gone early also, but I figure you guys put up with enough of my weirdness.

But. This video, an outtake, reminds me of how much I love all kinds of music. Forget your cool and sway along...

Broken YouTube Link

Easter egg:

Spoiler
Show
Broken YouTube Link

I wouldn't count musicals, except maybe that scene in Singing in the Rain where it's revealed that Debbie Reynolds is providing the voice.

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk


by BullyEyelash

I think she did briefly dancing in the park? But she’s a bookkeeper. Mick Jagger never played a musician unless it was himself or based on himself.

I actually deleted my post because I meant something different and realized it could have spoilers.

In my original post what I meant was what movies have a character who’s a musician but doesn’t play any music in the film? Like a movie with a writerblocked writer or injured/retired athlete.


by BullyEyelash

In my original post what I meant was what movies have a character who’s a musician but doesn’t play any music in the film? Like a movie with a writerblocked writer or injured/retired athlete.

Jagger wasn't really playing a version of himself but was playing a kind of washed up rock star in Performance. He does perform a number in the movie though.

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk


by BullyEyelash

In my original post what I meant was what movies have a character who’s a musician but doesn’t play any music in the film? Like a movie with a writerblocked writer or injured/retired athlete.

LOL



And not one person had the heart to pick the Partridge Family.


by lastcardcharlie

And not one person had the heart to pick the Partridge Family.

Thought about it! Think they’re ineligible though.


by BullyEyelash

Thought about it! Think they’re ineligible though.

I don't know. The show was based on a real band, The Cowsills, from Newport, RI. So a fake band playing a real band?

Anyway, I was considering the last scene of Fellini's 8 1/2. Or The Fabulous Stains.

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk


by John Cole

I wouldn't count musicals, except maybe that scene in Singing in the Rain where it's revealed that Debbie Reynolds is providing the voice.

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk

The musicals that are about bands or singers though should be 100% fine. I'm thinking stuff like New York New York or White Christmas. But I purposely didn't pick any of that stuff because I don't feel it captures the spirit of the draft.


I guess you're in overtime. My obvious pick was mentioned earlier, Spinal Tap.

My not-so-obvious pick:

Rush was known for their self-deprecating short films played prior to, during athe break, and after their shows. This was from the Time Machine tour (2011, I believe).

Murph and the Magictones was another I would've thrown out there.


by BullyEyelash

In my original post what I meant was what movies have a character who’s a musician but doesn’t play any music in the film? Like a movie with a writerblocked writer or injured/retired athlete.

This one time at band camp ...


Fingerbang! South Park's boy band.



https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/image...


by BullyEyelash

I’m taking the music class from Class of 1984: Perry King, Tim Van Patten, Michael J Fox, and Keanu Reeves.

John has next two then me again. Writeups later.


Michael J. Fox still kicks himself for not buying up all the prints of this when he could’ve. Completely ludicrous of course and a huge box office flop, but some pretty good performances; worth a watch if you liked The Warriors or Over The Edge maybe. Once Sixteen Candles was released this genre changed obviously.

Roddy McDowall wuz robbed of a BSA nom, but not as badly as Alice Cooper was for I Am The Future.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RQzquKK...

The topics of Best Songs Never Nominated For Best Song and Alice Cooper’s Forgotten/Disavowed 80s Albums deserve their own threads.

Reply...