If you lived in Minneapolis, and an ICE agent demand ID.....
If you lived in Minneapolis, and an ICE agent demand ID.....
8
zs

If you lived in Minneapolis, and an ICE agent demand ID.....

......would you comply. (You have broken no law. You're just walking into the grocery store.)

Why or Why not?

18 January 2026 at 04:26 PM
Reply...

1077 Replies

8
zs


did Kamala not support ICE? did she not pledge to give ICE record funding? at some point you guys gotta own what you voted for if you arent going to actually change your position.


At some point you gotta realize you’re beating an extinct horse that no one is arguing against.


An other case of a “lib” coming in, arguing a bunch of right wing points, getting punched in the mouth over and over, and digging in their heels to continue to push right wing nonsense

A tale as old as time


by whatthejish m

At some point you gotta realize you’re beating an extinct horse that no one is arguing against.

you are the one who brought it up. I am criticizing the governor for not protecting his people from the ICE thugs. his milquetoast response is bullshit and you should be outraged.


guys its fine, the most powerful person in the state asked the fascist thugs nicely to stop murdering and disappearing people. if you think he should do more and try to protect his constituents then you are the problem.


Victor, you supported all of this by being citizen of the US. Time for you to own it.


no **** man. also, theres no ethical consumption in capitalism. doesnt mean I gotta defend the US Empire like you guys do.


by Victor m

no **** man.

Oh, so it was dumb of me to point out the obvious? That’s what you post ALL THE TIME.


Ill remember that next time you guys point out how bad Trump is.


by Victor m

guys its fine, the most powerful person in the state asked the fascist thugs nicely to stop murdering and disappearing people. if you think he should do more and try to protect his constituents then you are the problem.

Its a tough position. Do you call in the national guard? Trump already threatened to send in 1500 US troops

Seems like that would escalate tensions

But yeah, ICE is just murdering people on the streets, so asking nicely probably wont help

Neither will starting a civil war


by coordi m

Its a tough position. Do you call in the national guard? Trump already threatened to send in 1500 US troops

Seems like that would escalate tensions

But yeah, ICE is just murdering people on the streets, so asking nicely probably wont help

Neither will starting a civil war

I wouldn't trust the National Guard. Walz and Frey could call in city and state cops to arrest and jail ICE and BP and let the courts work it out while ICE agents are in jail.


if Trump and the Repubs are fascist Nazi gangsters looking to round up all the libs and rule forever as you guys always say, then ya, civil war is the only way.


by microbet m

I wouldn't trust the National Guard. Walz and Frey could call in city and state cops to arrest and jail ICE and BP and let the courts work it out while ICE agents are in jail.

Interesting tactic

What happens when ICE resists arrest or tries to arrest local cops for interfering with federal activities?


https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgressiveHQ/c...

That one guy grabs a pepper spray bottle and starts smashing dude in the head/face with it
right before the other guy beside him pulls out his gun
and executes a guy with 5 people on top of him
then every ice officer is like running from the scene, they can't believe it happened either


I think it's pretty clear that there's going to be no agreements between left in right in this thread or in this country, until people make a real effort to get outside their respective media bubbles.

The right is just pushing nonsense and a line that "violent radical left agitators" are creating conditions where shootings of citizens can be justified. That's why this thread exists, correct? You should just shut up and comply.

The problem for me is, my media seems to cover these incidences fairly. I have some news sources that downplay some potential agitation that goes beyond most norms I've experienced first hand in my life (in these kinds of protest). But I find a huge reality gap between listening to far right news and far left news, and how they portray these incidences. I'm not sure how that's reconciled at all for people on the right, because they don't seem to want to understand another perspective here.

The crazy thing to me is, just like Jan 6th, Trump created the inevitable conditions that lead to people's deaths. And just like now, sending in massive amounts of ICE agents to blue cities, the inevitable killing and terrorizing was predictable. Trump will just walk away from both of these situations, claiming he had nothing to do w/ it... which is a level of sociopathy I can't quite fathom.

People justifying along w/ him, I think also need to reflect where they are on the sociopathy scale.

I hope no matter what, we consider moving forward, that a non-starter for ANY president (left, right, center, upside-down), should be someone who is pitting American's against fellow Americans. this is all madness on so many levels.


by coordi m

https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgressiveHQ/c...That one guy grabs a pepper spray bottle and starts smashing dude in the head/face with itright before the other guy beside him pulls out his gunand executes a guy with 5 p

They initially went after him because he threw a snowball at one of the agents, correct?

The spin on the right already is that he was armed (with a snowball)... but I guess he did have a gun. Video clearly shows they already took it away before shooting him though.

I saw the Fox new local live in real time as this happened right in front of their cameras. It was almost dystopian how they were talking about the whole situation. Once they realized what happened, they cut the feed. That footage is now removed from their site. At least I can't find it anymore.


by FreakDaddy m

They initially went after him because he threw a snowball at one of the agents, correct?The spin on the right already is that he was armed.... (with a snowball).I saw the Fox new local live in real time as this happened right in front of their cameras. It was almost dystopian how they were talking about the whole situation. Once they realized what happened, they cut the feed. T

The right is trying to push that he was armed with a gun

Well, we live in a country that allows carrying guns

You can't have it both ways, where 2a is foundational to the country then you execute people for utilizing their 2a right

And this is being generous and whole sale accepting that he did have a gun on him, which is questionable in itself


MN allows open carry, he was licensed. His gun was holstered the entire time until an ICE agent removed the gun from his holster and scurries away with it (you can see this in the video). He is then [strike]shot[/strike] executed while being pinned down a few moments later.


by coordi m

The right is trying to push that he was armed with a gun

Well, we live in a country that allows carrying guns

You can't have it both ways, where 2a is foundational to the country then you execute people for utilizing their 2a right

And this is being generous and whole sale accepting that he did have a gun on him, which is questionable in itself

Yes, them and the "don't tread on my crowd" claiming FAFO now is absurd... but when you score high on sociopathy, you can find absurd reasons to justify violence. At least that's what psychology tells us.

And I've seen multiple video angles now. He was armed, never even remotely went for his gun. They removed it after tackling him, and then shot him multiple times.


by Victor m

did Kamala not support ICE? did she not pledge to give ICE record funding? at some point you guys gotta own what you voted for if you arent going to actually change your position.

i mean the majority dem position today literally right now seems to be we need to give ice even more money!!! (for "better training"), so ??? enjoy arbys


by FreakDaddy m

I think it's pretty clear that there's going to be no agreements between left in right in this thread or in this country, until people make a real effort to get outside their respective media bubbles.The right is just pushing nonsense and a line that "violent radical left agitators" are creating conditions where shootings of citizens can be justified. That's why this thread exi

I'm curious does your media say they took a 5 year old and used him as bait ?

Though I do agree on the pitting Americans against fellow Americans and started under first Trump and continued under Biden and second term Trump


for "better training"

the training:



The craziest part id the agents aren't really doing anything needed. In the past presidents would understand the risks of these mass deployments. Obviously there is some bigotry of low expectations with Trump, modern ICE, the entire culture of supporters and nobody holds them to normal standards. But this is still just so unnecessary.


by Victor m

the training:

yeah they seem to have that down already, so i'm not sure what the extra money is for. a bonus for good results i guess Β―\_(ツπŸ˜‰_/Β―


I seem to remember leftists being furious that ICE had a budget bigger than 95% of other countries militaries but sure go off on that nonsense repeatedly

Reply...