Israel/Palestine thread

Israel/Palestine thread

Think this merits its own thread...

Discuss my fellow 2+2ers..

AM YISRAEL CHAI.

[QUOTE=Crossnerd]

07 October 2023 at 09:33 PM
Reply...

43274 Replies


Earlier posts are available on our legacy forum HERE

If Israel didn’t bomb a humanitarian aid ship someone else would have, right?

Right???


by 57 On Red

I don't think anyone had to be saved exactly. The drones seemed to be aiming small munitions at the ship's generator, on deck forward, and started a fire. The ship's position will have been relayed by the IDF C-130 which was orbiting the area for hours. Don't know what story the C-130 crew told Maltese ATC, if any, but Malta has no fighters and its air defence consists of old B

they put out an SOS and were rescued by a tugboat hours later

the drones would have flown through the airspace of many countries. and doesnt Europe have any air defense in the Mediterranean? if they wanted to stop Israel from bombing aid workers in the Mediterranean then they easily could have. but they like killing anyone who doesnt want to murder all of the Palestinians.


by gotwoot

If Israel didn’t bomb a humanitarian aid ship someone else would have, right?

Right???

I mean, I wouldnt put it past the Americans or the Brits. they love war crimes too.




by jalfrezi

Good to see checkraisdraw and dunyain finally arriving at the much predicted Ok it is a genocide but …. stage of the never ending massacre of men women and children.

I never said it was a genocide. I said genocide doesn’t impart a collective stain on an identity group. I don’t look at Germans or Turks as collectively stained because of the genocides committed by their people for instance.

by Victor

are you quoting Mein Kampf here?

Yeah, Mein Kampf famously said that we shouldn’t judge groups of individuals based off of the actions of a particular party in power at any time.


The starvation pics are starting.



by Victor

the drones would have flown through the airspace of many countries.

Between Israel and Malta? No, in a straight line it's all open sea and it's all international airspace.

and doesnt Europe have any air defense in the Mediterranean?

What do you mean by 'Europe'? The British sovereign bases on Cyprus are a sensitive area, but they don't maintain fighters on QRA (Cyprus itself is not in NATO), only point defence by missiles, and the line of flight was nowhere near Cyprus, and it probably passed far enough from Crete to avoid triggering Greek NATO QRA. The southern littoral of the Med is outside the NATO area and Malta is constitutionally neutral and not a NATO member.

What Malta International's civil ATC made of an Israeli military C-130 orbiting in the neighbourhood for hours I don't know, but the ship was anchored well out in international waters and not a Maltese responsibility at that time. In any case there was nothing the Maltese could do militarily, as the Israelis no doubt knew.

if they wanted to stop Israel from bombing aid workers in the Mediterranean then they easily could have.

No, they couldn't have done a thing. No air-defence radar, no missiles, no fighters, nothing. That would be factored into the Israeli plan.

but they like killing anyone who doesnt want to murder all of the Palestinians.

The Maltese government is bad and corrupt, and it tends to co-operate with Israel, but this is controversial in Malta and a couple of years ago there were calls, including from a former president, to withdraw the ambassador from Tel Aviv and sever diplomatic relations on account of Israel's constant violations of international law.


it looks like the drone was launched by an aircraft that circled the flotilla for awhile.

and I mean all of European govt want to kill anyone pro-Palestine, not just Malta. put it this way, Russia isnt flying any planes over the Mediterranean.


by Victor

it looks like the drone was launched by an aircraft that circled the flotilla for awhile.

Whether the C-130 launched the drones is not known at this point. It's not a flotilla, it's a single ship.

and I mean all of European govt want to kill anyone pro-Palestine, not just Malta.

That's crazytalk.

put it this way, Russia isnt flying any planes over the Mediterranean.

When you consider what Russia did in Syria and what it's still doing in Ukraine, that's crazytalk again, apart from being irrelevant.


whatever Russia has ever done is childs play compared to what Israel and the USA has done. including in Syria.

but the point wasnt meant to have anything to do with Russia itself. the point is that aircraft and bombs do not get into that area with explicit acceptance by the European and American genocidal regimes.


Israel is bombing the **** out of Syria right now lol. they are bombing like 4 different areas. tell me more about the bad Russians.


So all of Victors nonsense about flotillas and massacres is over one (allegedly Israeli) drone taking out the engine of one ship without even a single injury?


by Victor

Israel is bombing the **** out of Syria right now lol. they are bombing like 4 different areas. tell me more about the bad Russians.

The true moral compromise going on here is Europe and the Trump administration being completely agnostic to all the pogroms and massacres going on in Syria, and leaving it to Israel on its own to protect civilians from slaughter.


by Dunyain

The true moral compromise going on here is Europe and the Trump administration being completely agnostic to all the pogroms and massacres going on in Syria, and leaving it to Israel on its own to protect civilians from slaughter.

Trump just doesn't give a ****, Europe Is actually actively siding with the Syrian Islamic radicals


by Dunyain

So all of Victors nonsense about flotillas and massacres is over one (allegedly Israeli) drone taking out the engine of one ship without even a single injury?

allegedly

by Dunyain

The true moral compromise going on here is Europe and the Trump administration being completely agnostic to all the pogroms and massacres going on in Syria, and leaving it to Israel on its own to protect civilians from slaughter.

this is the height of bad faith. Israel and the USA created the situation in Syria. the tankies told you guys for over a decade that the "moderate rebels" funded by nearly a trillion dollars of Western cash and weapons were actually ISIS.


by Victor

Israel is bombing the **** out of Syria right now lol. they are bombing like 4 different areas. tell me more about the bad Russians.

The Russians are still bombing the **** out of Ukraine, with your unqualified slavish dictator-worshipping approval.


by Luciom

Trump just doesn't give a ****, Europe Is actually actively siding with the Syrian Islamic radicals

Europe has been bought and paid for by Qatar.

Trump has too; but there is no indication he would have cared regardless.


but we have already established that bombing the **** out of a country does not disqualify a country from using European airspace to bomb humanitarian flotillas. wake me up when Russia does that btw.

the reason is bc the European leaders want to kill all the Palestinians bc it benefits them.


by 57 On Red

The Russians are still bombing the **** out of Ukraine, with your unqualified slavish dictator-worshipping approval.

If you haven’t noticed, only like 10% of what Victor types out is rooted in any form of truth.


the Russian war has really laid bare the absolute hypocrisy of the West. when Russia acts even 1% as disgusting as the USA or Israel then its a massive story. the fact is that no one can compare to the depravity towards civilians we are witnessing in Palestine, Lebanon, and Syria.

every accusation is a confession and when the Western slappies try to tell you about Bucha just remember that Israel is doing a Bucha multiple times a day for over a year.


by Victor

but we have already established that bombing the **** out of a country does not disqualify a country from using European airspace to bomb humanitarian flotillas. wake me up when Russia does that btw.

the reason is bc the European leaders want to kill all the Palestinians bc it benefits them.

I wish that was true and they realized that and acted toward with full force that but they don't realize that and they don't act toward that.

there are actually far more politicians agreeing with you and siding with Hamas in Europe (even in positions of actual power like the leaders in Spain and Ireland) than in the USA.


The notion that European nations want to eradicate all of the Palestinians is lunacy and completely disconnected from reality. EU nations are condemning Israel more than the Arab nations.



every accusation...


by Luciom

I wish that was true and they realized that and acted toward with full force that but they don't realize that and they don't act toward that.

there are actually far more politicians agreeing with you and siding with Hamas in Europe (even in positions of actual power like the leaders in Spain and Ireland) than in the USA.

Hot take, it’s not good to eradicate all Palestinians or all Israelis. Crazy, I know.



This girl?


Hm..

Reply...