Israel/Palestine thread

Israel/Palestine thread

Think this merits its own thread...

Discuss my fellow 2+2ers..

AM YISRAEL CHAI.

[QUOTE=Crossnerd]

07 October 2023 at 09:33 PM
Reply...

43274 Replies


Earlier posts are available on our legacy forum HERE

by Victor

doesnt seem to require Israel to release their hostages.

and I do wonder how many hostages Hamas has left. I thought it was almost all military. so they should be called POWs.

Nobody besides you calls non active personelle who may have served their 2 years or if obligation not are now civilians military. I think even hamas calls them hostages

And hi all


by Luckbox Inc

Is this just a semantic argument where prisoners are not hostages?

It's not semantics


by Victor

Coincidentally what are your thoughts on Bobby Sands?

What has Bobby Sands got to do with Israel?


by Luckbox Inc

Is this just a semantic argument where prisoners are not hostages?

No


by metsandfinsfan

Nobody besides you calls non active personelle who may have served their 2 years or if obligation not are now civilians military. I think even hamas calls them hostages

And hi all

How many are non-active?

Also, what do you call a non-active Hamas member?


by Victor

How many are non-active?

Also, what do you call a non-active Hamas member?

Lol got ‘em


by PointlessWords

Israel has 2000+ Palestinian hostage/torture victims. With a 99.7% conviction rate and 300+ people being held without seeing a judge or a charge, life is terrible for many Palestinians

a lot more than 2k. the numbers I have seen are 7500+ arrested in the West Bank since Oct 7. so thats not even counting who was there prior nor all the Gazans that are being tortured in black sites.


by Victor

How many are non-active?

Also, what do you call a non-active Hamas member?

participation in Hamas isn't mandated by law (afaik).


by Luciom

participation in Hamas isn't mandated by law (afaik).

Nobody gives a ****. He wasn’t asking about that


by PointlessWords

Nobody gives a ****. He wasn’t asking about that

an ex-conscript isn't an ex-military in the sense of sharing responsibilitt for joining the military or for the bad actions of the military.

anyone who ever participated in Hamas or helped Hamas in any way is, for life, a person who dealt in, or helped, terrorism, which is one of the worst possible things a person can be.


by Luciom

an ex-conscript isn't an ex-military in the sense of sharing responsibilitt for joining the military or for the bad actions of the military.

anyone who ever participated in Hamas or helped Hamas in any way is, for life, a person who dealt in, or helped, terrorism, which is one of the worst possible things a person can be.

We aren’t talking about that. Stfu


by Luciom

participation in Hamas isn't mandated by law (afaik).

according to western sources young men are conscripted into service and tortured if they refuse. also their families can be harassed and arrested.

no idea if its true! read it in Huff Post...


by PointlessWords

We aren’t talking about that. Stfu

i am, and you are. victor claims that if Hamas captures an ex-military that's not an hostage, rather a pow.

while he claims Hamas people captured are hostages lol.


by Victor

according to western sources young men are conscripted into service and tortured if they refuse. also their families can be harassed and arrested.

no idea if its true! read it in Huff Post...

by Hamas?


by Luciom

i am, and you are. victor claims that if Hamas captures an ex-military that's not an hostage, rather a pow.

while he claims Hamas people captured are hostages lol.

no I dont claim any of this.

I literally just asked how many were active military.

and its completely absurd to think that the 10s of thousands in Israeli jails and torture camps are all Hamas.


by Victor

no I dont claim any of this.

I literally just asked how many were active military.

and its completely absurd to think that the 10s of thousands in Israeli jails and torture camps are all Hamas.

lol torture camps


by Luciom

i am, and you are. victor claims that if Hamas captures an ex-military that's not an hostage, rather a pow.

while he claims Hamas people captured are hostages lol.

Please stop making things up and then trying to arguing against them. You’re gaslighting


by Dunyain

Do you think the current dynamic of holding Israel to a higher standard (which I guess involves ridiculing their religion) and holding Palestinians to absolutely no standard is working out well? I would say it is not working out particularly well.

I ridicule all religions pretty equally.


by Victor

according to western sources young men are conscripted into service and tortured if they refuse. also their families can be harassed and arrested.

no idea if its true! read it in Huff Post...

How is that possible, i heard Israel controled Gaza all these years how can the puppet regime do this?


by Victor

no I dont claim any of this.

I literally just asked how many were active military.

and its completely absurd to think that the 10s of thousands in Israeli jails and torture camps are all Hamas.

Many are just criminals who may not be hamas


by 57 On Red

The Israelis are now in quite a difficult position if they proceed with the assault on Rafah and if they keep blocking aid.

I don't see how they can do all this and leave the rafah tunnels untouched.


by metsandfinsfan

How is that possible, i heard Israel controled Gaza all these years how can the puppet regime do this?

Hamas is not a puppet regime. they are a resistance force.


todays edition of all their accusations are confessions



this is why people post things about the PTSD of Israeli children while ignoring the murdered Palestinian children who have been beheaded, buried alive, and burned alive.



by Victor

Hamas is not a puppet regime. they are a resistance force.

Ya

Reply...