General TV Discussion and Thread for Shows Without A Thread Thread

General TV Discussion and Thread for Shows Without A Thread Thread

OOTV doesnt like family comedies much huh? Raising Hope and The Middle are two of the best(possibly the best outside of NBC)comedies on tv yet no threads.

Just an observation.

) 4 Views 4
10 November 2010 at 05:31 PM
Reply...

917 Replies

5
w


Really good season finale for Hacks.

Spoiler
Show

The ending is where I hoped it would towards the end of last season. Their scene right before the end was easily Hannah's best performed scene of the series.

I don't know if it's been renewed for season 4 yet, but I'm worried we won't get one. Or at least it won't be for quite awhile.


by 72off k

now netflix seems to have only tentatively renewed it for "additional episodes", which might mean just 4-8 more eps to wrap up the series. their announcement was extremely vague, i don't think they even really know yet. which means they could just end up canceling it altogether. but it seems unlikely now that it will get 4 full seasons like they originally hoped.

Sounds like they're testing the waters to see if the audience is there. There is literally a huge amount left in the series.

Minor book spoiler below.

Spoiler
Show

The 3rd book "Death's End" ends a few billion years in the future.


by Kurn, son of Mogh k

Sounds like they're testing the waters to see if the audience is there.

They already know the answer to that question and the announcement was their response to it.

Another option would be more episodes for less money per episode but D&D probably don't want that because that might interfere with their "artistic freedom".


yeah i think the problem with 3bp is that they spent waaayyy too much money on it for whatever reason. i heard that d&d went over budget with it (shocking), not sure by how much though. resulted in one of the most expensive shows out there, which seems completely unnecessary for what it is. and then massive cost demands probably impossible viewership numbers. but then they dropped it all at once, which kind of seems like they gave up on it ahead of time. anyway, predictably it wasn't a massive hit and now here we are.

obviously plans can change, and i could be wrong, but from what i understood their announcement the other day said that however many episodes they put out for season 2 (if any) will be the end of it. i guess the emmy nominations come out in july, and if anything can turn the situation around it might be winning some awards. but then again maybe not, who knows.


by 72off k

yeah i think the problem with 3bp is that they spent waaayyy too much money on it for whatever reason. i heard that d&d went over budget with it (shocking), not sure by how much though. resulted in one of the most expensive shows out there, which seems completely unnecessary for what it is. and then massive cost demands probably impossible viewership numbers. but then they dropped it all at once, which kind of seems like they gave up on it ahead of time. anyway, predictably it wasn't a massive h

Oh, well. Maybe I'll go back to the Chinese version on Prime. 54 episodes.


by 72off k

yeah i think the problem with 3bp is that they spent waaayyy too much money on it for whatever reason. i heard that d&d went over budget with it (shocking), not sure by how much though. resulted in one of the most expensive shows out there, which seems completely unnecessary for what it is. and then massive cost demands probably impossible viewership numbers. but then they dropped it all at once, which kind of seems like they gave up on it ahead of time. anyway, predictably it wasn't a massive h

I watched one episode and liked it. But then I saw the viewership was down so I quit. That's a Netflix problem as I don't trust them to finish shows.


by Kurn, son of Mogh k

Oh, well. Maybe I'll go back to the Chinese version on Prime. 54 episodes.

is the show better or the books?


Anyone feel like Outer Range reminds them of Lost; a show trying to find answers to questions it doesnt know how to ask? It feels like each episode the writers are just winging it, as in they want to come up with something interesting but lack the creativity to conclude it. I feel like the ScreenRant Pitch Meeting guy could have a field day with their writing.

Producer: hey make me a cool show we can stretch out for 8 seasons if we had to.

Writer: Ok, but the only idea I've come up with so far is a mysterious black hole in a field

Producer: Lets run with it, maybe time travel?

Writer: yeah yeah yeah! Ok, so the heroes go back in time and encounter people they know from before they were born

Producer: wow this is going to get complicated with all of the paradox implications

Writer: actually it'll be super easy, barely an inconvenience! You see each person who goes back in time will have absolutely no bearing on their future timelines, yet in the future there are hallmarks of their time travel to interconnect their past with their present! But none of it will have any real consequences.

Producer: Perfect! Make sure to randomly introduce 'mysterious' characters along the way who sound highly intellectual with profound wisdom of all things in the universe but dont really contribute or influence anything in the show whatsoever

Like I swear, the 2 writers feel like they probably assumed this time travel stuff cant be that hard, after all Back to the Future didnt require a PhD to write, and then half way through writing each episode they just get stuck looking at each other with a "now what?" expression on their face until someone just pulls something out of their ass to move the story along.


Finished The Sympathizer. I do recommend it but be ready to read a lot. With most shows, I prefer to doodle on my geetar but this show is sort of all over the place so I needed to pay closer attention. I don’t mean that in a bad way. It time jumps constantly but it works. And Robert Downey Jr plays 4 different characters, all very well!


by SerOuanling k

is the show better or the books?

The books are excellent. In some ways, a strange and convoluted story, but it works. First 50-100 pages, I was like "How is this SciFi?" Then it kicks in. One part that hooked me was a look at a modern Chinese author's description of aspects of life in modern China as the underpinning to the story.

The Netflix show does a great job of distilling the main plot points of the first book, but it changes the location to the UK and changes the ethnicity/gender of some of the characters (this does not get in the way of the plot lines, though).

The Chinese series on Prime is structurally weird to me as a westerner, and it seems to move very slowly getting to the main plot points, but I'm only 10 episodes in and it is nowhere near the end of the first book.


by javi k

Anyone feel like Outer Range reminds them of Lost; a show trying to find answers to questions it doesnt know how to ask? It feels like each episode the writers are just winging it, as in they want to come up with something interesting but lack the creativity to conclude it. I feel like the ScreenRant Pitch Meeting guy could have a field day with their writing.

Producer: hey make me a cool show we can stretch out for 8 seasons if we had to.

Writer: Ok, but the only idea I've come up with so far i

I get some of this sentiment, but that's also just a joyless way to watch TV. Believe me I understand why some need it all to make sense, but I stopped worrying so much about that.

As it relates to Perry

Spoiler
Show

My wife mentioned it too when he died. I'm just of the mind that when the timeline loses you, if your other is there to keep it all going, then the timeline is satisfied (and it's their rules so who cares frankly). But maybe then you can never leave (if you want to keep that character going). Regardless it feels like they're setting us up for a big rewind that'll smooth it all over anyway


First 2 episodes of The Acolyte are good not great. I thought some of the acting was bad but it happened during the worst writing so not sure if the actor(s) are to blame.

Spoiler
Show

There is a 5 minute sequence where we learn Mae is alive, that Sol hid that Mae existed at all, Sol insists there is no way Mae could be alive, then Sol runs into Isha who tells him Mae is alive and that Sol "believes her". Just a whiplash sequence all around. I'm guessing the twist is these Jedi Masters left Mae to die because she was evil and powerful as a child.


Presumed Innocent on AppleTV

I'd pretty much watch anything with Jake Gyllenhaal at this point and this was a very solid first episode


Restarted 3 Body Problem. I don't really know what is going on but it is keeping me engaged every episode.


by Eltin k

Presumed Innocent on AppleTV

I'd pretty much watch anything with Jake Gyllenhaal at this point and this was a very solid first episode

I agree with the first part but I'm assuming you've never seen the movie or you couldn't possibly have liked the 1st episode.


Dark Matter on Apple has been getting interesting lately, two more episodes to go apparently.

I've also watched half of Ripley, really liked it so far.


by Kurn, son of Mogh k

The Chinese series on Prime is structurally weird to me as a westerner, and it seems to move very slowly getting to the main plot points, but I'm only 10 episodes in and it is nowhere near the end of the first book.

i've never been able to fully embrace chinese film/tv culture because the structure is just beyond bizarre and the entire time i just think about what I'd have done if i were in charge of editing instead of just enjoying it for what it was

the wandering earth is also based on a book by the same novelist, it was one of the biggest films the yer it came out - i recommend watching it, but as you will see, not even the trailer makes sense to a westerner

the film is an incredible visual treat and deals with new and novel concepts so i strongly rec watching it, but there's going to be a good 2-3 dozen times you're left with a "wtf why would they do that" and it's not bad writing/production, it's just asians being asians and making decisions that make utterly no sense to us whatsoever


by riverboatking k

I agree with the first part but I'm assuming you've never seen the movie or you couldn't possibly have liked the 1st episode.

Nope, didnt even know it was based on a movie. Worth a watch then i guess? Probably a good idea wait until after the show now


by Mark_K k

Regarding Hacks,

Did anyone think the shower scene felt out of place? I'm not arguing, who doesn't like lesbian boobies but idk but it seems like it was inserted just for the nudity. This in a show without previous nudity.

i binged it while sick recently

shower scene felt way out of place, i liked it, but it was way out of place, then shortly after they have the wholly unnecessary nude pta meeting which served zero plot purpose whatsoever (my guess is they were probably contractually obligated to give that asian girl some screen time so slammed that in much like they brute forced her briefly into an episode of season 2 as well - she also have gained a ton of weight since her last role)

so after seeing all these needless titties out of the blue, i'm now beginning to think perhaps it's a new show runner or they decided to make it sexier a la typical hbo playbook of titties sprinkled in whenever - but then no more

by DC11GTR k

Really good season finale for Hacks.

Spoiler
Show

The ending is where I hoped it would towards the end of last season. Their scene right before the end was easily Hannah's best performed scene of the series.

I don't know if it's been renewed for season 4 yet, but I'm worried we won't get one. Or at least it won't be for quite awhile.

it got renewed for a 4th season last month - but agree that means it could be a while given we had a 2 year break between 2 & 3

did not like the ending

Spoiler
Show

it felt really stupid because she'd already worked with that other writer and basically ignored him and brought in her girl anyway so it made no sense to me - just felt like an arbitrary hiccup thrown in there to cause artificial tension


by Eltin k

Nope, didnt even know it was based on a movie. Worth a watch then i guess? Probably a good idea wait until after the show now

the movie is phenomenal.

they've basically gotten rid of all the best parts from the movie (well obv the acting across the board in the film was elite the musical score awesome and the writing exceptional so there was a bunch they were never gonna be able to replicate) so don't think it matters if you watch the movie they are not including any of the awesome twists in the film so won't get spoiled but it will probably make the series worse so maybe that's reason enough to wait.

but def make sure you watch the movie at some point because it's absolutely fantastic.


by Eltin k

Anyone watching Sugar with Colin Farrell on Apple TV? There is supposed to be

Spoiler
Show

a big twist thats insane/absurd halfway the show. Some reviewers seem to love it, and some seem to hate it.

So im very intrigued.

I thought the first episode of the 3 currently out was great. Excited for more.

Way behind but just binged this show. I thought the twist was a serious "wtf", but ended up liking the series and could go for another season.


by riverboatking k

the movie is phenomenal.

they've basically gotten rid of all the best parts from the movie (well obv the acting across the board in the film was elite the musical score awesome and the writing exceptional so there was a bunch they were never gonna be able to replicate) so don't think it matters if you watch the movie they are not including any of the awesome twists in the film so won't get spoiled but it will probably make the series worse so maybe that's reason enough to wait.

but def make sure y

Isn't it supposed to be another adaptation of the book not a remake of the movie?

FWIW, it's been a very long time since I've watched the movie but IIRC I thought it was good but certainly not fantastic. Definitely not my favorite Harrison Ford movie from that time.

To me it would be pretty boring if the TV show was just like the movie.


BIG discussion containing a spoiler for Presumed Innocent. Do not click if you haven’t read the book / seen the movie.

Spoiler
Show

I mean it. This is your last warning.

Spoiler
Show

one of the funniest / meanest stories I ever heard was one of my buddies had a friend who drove past a huge line of people waiting outside the movie theater to see this when it first opened and he yelled out

Spoiler
Show

The Wife Did It!


by madlex k

Isn't it supposed to be another adaptation of the book not a remake of the movie?

FWIW, it's been a very long time since I've watched the movie but IIRC I thought it was good but certainly not fantastic. Definitely not my favorite Harrison Ford movie from that time.

To me it would be pretty boring if the TV show was just like the movie.

except so far (and according to every review I've read) they don't introduce anything particularly new or clever or interesting they just got rid of all the best parts of the book/movie.


The Curse. Nathan Fielder, Emma Stone, Benny Safdie.

Only watched the first episode last night, but what an episode it was. I have no way to describe it other than it being a mashup of Fielder and Safdie's minds and senses of humour. Will continue and see where it goes.

Reply...