Israel/Palestine thread

Israel/Palestine thread

Think this merits its own thread...

Discuss my fellow 2+2ers..

AM YISRAEL CHAI.

[QUOTE=Crossnerd]

07 October 2023 at 09:33 PM
Reply...

43274 Replies


Earlier posts are available on our legacy forum HERE

Vic, were have you been outside of the us?


by chezlaw

I've banged on a lot about Turkey. They are going to be a key factor this century and we will likely pay a big price for not welcoming and supporting them them when they were moving our way.Possibly the biggest geopolitical mistake of my lifetime. Although since then we have had a few doozies.Of course this may provide some stability for Israel but then again it may eventually

I dont know the exact context of your Turkey related post, but my understanding is that even in its early history when Turkey was more secular and pro Western; it still was extremely nationalistic and undertook severe repression and human rights abuses of its minority populations, including actual genocide much worse than what is going on in the Palestinian Territories (as evidenced by population collapse of minority groups).

Western society is a little more jaded now, and more or less looks the other way when "allies" commit human right abuses, but at the time was more idealistic; so this was a big reason to be "unwelcoming."

Also, for geopolitical reasons Israel has always been restrained in how it can respond to rhetoric and actions taken against them. I dont see how Turkey becoming more influential would change much in this respect.


by Victor

I dont think Western society is superior and certainly not "inherently" which could be construed some pretty bad ways fwiw

Ironically, the elites everywhere else clearly disagree with this; which is a big reason why Western society has as much leverage as it does with nations like Russia, Iran and China; even while their actual economic/military influence has waned. Because their elites dont want to end up shunned from polite society.

Russia can make all the economic and military alliances it wants with North Korea and Iran; but the elites would never want their children to grow up in those places like they do with England and France. And wanting to be reintroduced back into polite society is as much an incentive for Putin to seek a resolution to the Ukraine mess (that allows him to save as much face as possible) as anything.


by IMBLUEtheONE

The western society is inherently superior. You would have known that, If you ever travelled or lived in any part of the world.

Take a year to do so, speak to people who live in different parts of the world, and then lets continue this conversation

I'd dispute that. Things are different and "superiority" is a stupid word to use because it's meaningless, but it says much about the people who use it in this context.


its really funny for these guys just out and out say that the West is superior when I have been banned for calling out that very sentiment.


by jalfrezi

I'd dispute that. Things are different and "superiority" is a stupid word to use because it's meaningless, but it says much about the people who use it in this context.

said the man who will never travel or live in any other country but the US.

Also, I was quoting Karl, but correcting his claim.

And the white supremist do not have an intellectual right on this word.


by IMBLUEtheONE

indeed sigh

I had correctly stated that Hamas started October 07. I never once stated that was the start of the Israel/Palestine conflict in general and made this clear to victor.


by Victor

its really funny for these guys just out and out say that the West is superior when I have been banned for calling out that very sentiment.

Why you did not answer my question?


by corpus vile

I had correctly stated that Hamas started October 07. I never once stated that was the start of the Israel/Palestine conflict in general and made this clear to victor.

that's why I sighed. he obv knows that, but argues in bad faith


by IMBLUEtheONE

said the man who will never travel or live in any other country but the US.

Also, I was quoting Karl, but correcting his claim.

And the white supremist do not have an intellectual right on this word.

1. I'm British
2. I've lived in West Africa
3. You're almost always wrong


by IMBLUEtheONE

Why you did not answer my question?

which one? thread was moving pretty fast there. I can answer now. ask me anything budday...


by corpus vile

He was taking the piss, Jasus. Israel isn't committing genocide. Being in the IDF doesn't make one evil by virtue of the fact.

So anyone can say anything and if they say "oh I was just taking a piss" it's forgiven? I don't think that's how things work, but from your denial of the factual genocide committed by Israel, you're obviously in the "say anything" mode of communication. You have devoted yourself to the principle of violence over understanding and what you say is proudly disconnected from reality. With your denial of genocide you are asserting that might make right and words don't matter. Maybe you are right about that dynamic but your words certainly don't matter once you go that route. I don't listen to Netanyahoo speak because there is no information in what he says. The same goes for his ghoul nation of sycophants. There is no information in your words and no ideas, only hatred.

I won't review here the facts of the genocide case against Israel any more than I would review the facts of the Holocaust to a Holocaust denier. Great company you keep btw.


by jalfrezi

1. I'm British
2. I've lived in West Africa
3. You're almost always wrong

Oh British. that explains a lot.

Where is west Africa?


by Victor

which one? thread was moving pretty fast there. I can answer now. ask me anything budday...

did you travel or lived outside of the US?


by IMBLUEtheONE

Oh British. that explains a lot.

Where is west Africa?

Where is West Africa?

I mean.........LOOOOOOOOL


no, Im gonna avoid giving that sort of personal info out


by Deuces McKracken

So anyone can say anything and if they say "oh I was just taking a piss" it's forgiven? I don't think that's how things work, but from your denial of the factual genocide committed by Israel, you're obviously in the "say anything" mode of communication. You have devoted yourself to the principle of violence over understanding and what you say is proudly disconnected from realit

who asked for forgiveness?


by Victor

Im just saying that US and Israel executed, tortured, raped, enslaved, and incarcerated far more people in West Asia in the 2000s than Assad could even dream.

It's cool when we do it because we feel bad about it afterwards.


by jalfrezi

Where is West Africa?

I mean.........LOOOOOOOOL

I admit that joke went over my head.


Sounds like you're the one who needs to experience different countries rather than adopt the childish position of "mine is always superior".


by jalfrezi

Sounds like you're the one who needs to experience different countries.

I travelled to Guinea, Mali, Nigeria and Senegal. also was supposed to go to Benin but didnt make it.

still confused


While working for the military?


by jalfrezi

While working for the military?

Nope. now explain the joke and the condescending posts.


You claim to have been to several countries in West Africa but didn't know where West Africa is.

What were you doing in those countries? Spying?


what are you on about? I asked where you lived in west africa, as i travelled threw some of the countries.

Vic and you make arguments in your head and then debate them for an hour. I was just wondering if I travelled threw where you lived at.

Reply...