Codenames League - Match Thread A

Cloak
Shadow
Duck

Ninja?
Face?
Plot?

Cloak
Ninja
Face
Moon

For me

Shadow is more "cover" for me

You cover your tracks more than conceal them, but it's still worth considering

Not feeling plot, but maybe

Duck I'm imagining is duck out of the way. I prefer cover again for this.

Why moon?

Just vibes I guess. Happy to bump it down if you want.

I assumed conceal was there to pick up cloak, specifically, vs the alternatives like cover. But we're trying to read PG's mind here (as usual) with a lot of fine distinctions.

Combining our lists, I think I'd land on

Cloak
Ninja
Face
Shadow
Pass

Moon
Duck
Track

After cloak I'm not certain on the order, so you can bold what you're feeling

Cloak
Ninja
Face
Shadow
Pass

Moon
Duck
Track

terrain - 7
conceal - 4

Carrot
Day
Death
Duck
Game
Iron
March
Moon
Play
Plot
Pool
Queen
Slug
Track
Water

Forest
Rock
Grass
Himalayas
Egypt

Antarctica
Cloak
Ninja
Face

Shadow

beach - 2

water and day?

then track to make up terrain

moon is never ours otherwise this would be unlimited

Water's a lock.

Pool/Water would be really easy to hit with dive or swim. But we're on beach which a pool doesn't have. So I hate Pool here.

Moon/Water you'd hit with tides much better than beach.

I like Play or Day with water.

That leaves terrain. Track was next on our list, but then there has to be one more. Not sure he'd re-clue water unless he thought we'd NEVER go there since we were taking terrain very literally.

March? Plot?

Nice crosspost.

The one thing I hate about Day here is Day is so dang generic.

Day/Water I really have a hard time seeing clued as beach. If you're trying NOT to hit pool, why even get in the neighborhood of swimming at all?

May be something like snow. A Snow Day is very definitely a thing.

Play/Water, while avoiding pool, is much harder.

Okay I think I'm convinced on play over day here.

ok i think i agree on play>day

something like

water
play
track
pass

day (for beach)
march
plot

Don't think any other word works with terrain much

Water
Play
Track
Pass
Day
March
Plot

terrain - 7
conceal - 4
beach - 2

Carrot
Day
Death
Duck
Game
Iron
March
Moon
Plot
Pool
Queen
Slug
Track

Forest
Rock
Grass
Himalayas
Egypt
Water

Antarctica
Cloak
Ninja
Face

Shadow
Play

May - unlimited

May Day is a cert

March is a cert

Then we need 2 backup words otherwise we'd have a 3 clue or a 4 clue.

I guess Moon and duck since they're our first 2 backups and track is first on their backup list.

Day
March
Moon
Duck
Bottles

bump for Zurvan

Sorry, crazy weekend. I think xander got it

Day
March
Moon
Duck
Bottles

Track

terrain - 7
conceal - 4
beach - 2
May - unlimited

Carrot
Death
Duck
Game
Iron
March
Moon
Plot
Pool
Queen
Slug
Track

Forest
Rock
Grass
Himalayas
Egypt
Water
Day

Antarctica
Cloak
Ninja
Face

Shadow
Play

IT WAS DAY

Oh, that sucks