New Draft Idea: Fake Bands/Musicians From Movies/TV

New Draft Idea: Fake Bands/Musicians From Movies/TV

Haven't had a good draft in awhile...so let's have one where we draft your favorite bands and/or musicians from the worl

23 May 2025 at 02:24 AM
Reply...

229 Replies


Earlier posts are available on our legacy forum HERE

The performers in this film did work together before making the movie, but the film itself is fiction. A busker on the streets of Dublin, whose full time job is repairing vacuum cleaners, meets a young woman who longs for a musical career.

I love these heartfelt small films that often go unnoticed on first release. A great John Carney film.

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk


Oh crap I didn't even think of including those two, John. I'm ashamed.

Two of my favorite movies ever. Of course they count.


by Dominic

Oh crap I didn't even think of including those two, John. I'm ashamed.

Two of my favorite movies ever. Of course they count.

I guess I'm catching on to this. [emoji16]

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk


lol but you should've include the whole band with Victor in Local Hero! I love the somber instrumental they play, as well.


by Dominic

lol but you should've include the whole band with Victor in Local Hero! I love the somber instrumental they play, as well.

I’d allow it.


With my third pick I’m taking Schroeder & The Peanuts Gang! Like Springsteen did when he got back to Jersey from Cali, Schro got back from Julliard, called a meeting, and told the boys (and girls and dog and birds), “I’m the star here”.

The piano, standup bass, sax/mouth harp-tuner round out my current band, and there are TWO drummers, to allow for some Allman Bros-Bitches Brew-Butthole Surfers jamming.

Plus a children’s choir for the spooky voodoo stuff, with Woodstock & his friends keeping watch on the vampires from the trees.



Picks so far:

Irish Vampire Band from Sinners
Lazarus from Black Snake Moan (write up coming later tonight)
Peanuts Gang


Round Three
The Barden Bellas
- Pitch Perfect(s)

The Pitch Perfect movies are a pure joy to watch. And the main character of these movies are the Bardon Bellas. A couple of weeks ago I posted in the music thread how much I loved vocal harmonies. These movies have that in spades! I can watch this stuff anytime I come across and can't stop until its over.

so far:
Otis Day and the Knights
Sweet Sue and Her Society Syncopaters
The Barden Bellas


Spoiler
Show


And Pig Pen wearing a garlic clove necklace will keep the vampires on their best behavior.


Round 3

I will go a little different... back to the Roots

Red Rocking Chair
Lisa Blount in Chrystal (2005)

I have a Great fondness for 'Roots' music and the south... this touches my soul.

R1- The Rubber Band
R2- Jan Pehechan ho
R3- Red Rocking Chair


round 3 pick:

Band: Eddie & the Cruisers

Great, shaggy dog mystery movie about a Jim Morrison-like figure named Eddie who supposedly died in a car wreck at the height of band's fame in the 60s...but his body was never found. Is he still alive? Ellen Barkin is trying to finds out by interviewing all Eddie's former bandmates and friends.

It's a fun movie...but what makes the movie is the music. John Cafferty and the Beaver Brown Band do all the music in a Springsteen pastiche, and Michael Pare does a fantastic job as the titular Eddie. It's a corny movie, but man, is the music fun.

*****

My picks:

The Wonders from That Thing You Do
Sam from Casablanca
Eddie & the Cruisers from Eddie and the Cruisers


Phat Mac on the clock!


Beaver Brown is a RI band. Used to see them all the time at the local bars.

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk


There is a whole genre of Japanese movie about outcast high school girls who find redemption by forming or joining bands. My next two picks are two of my favorites:

PARA MAUM In Linda Linda Linda -- a seminal Japanese Punk song.

Broken YouTube Link

and, the

SWING GIRLS in Swing Girls with its bad girls in a fun and incomprehensible plot.

Broken YouTube Link

Sniped twice with the Bells and Eddie!

Dom notified


4th round pick:

The Commitments

A bunch of Irish musicians want to play the Blues. Just a fun, amazing movie, with some of the best unknown musicians on the planet and directed by the massively underrated Alan Parker. Glen Hansard makes his second appearance in this draft after John Cole picks him in Once.

Spectacular songs, of course...but even more spectacular performances - especially by Andrew Strong, the singer in the below clip.

******

My picks:

The Wonders from That Thing You Do
Sam from Casablanca
Eddie & the Cruisers from Eddie and the Cruisers
The Commitments from The Commitments


Mschu18 on the clock!


Phat Mack, I assume you liked the outcast high school girl in Kill Bill?


by BullyEyelash

I’m taking Lazarus from Black Snake Moan but have to do write up later.


Much like Alice Cooper’s friendship with Keith Moon, the well-named Lazarus is the only musician in the draft who can hang with IVB, both onstage and off, and live to tell the tales.

Literally.


Good with the ladies too, but like Moon, it could go sideways badly after a few too many.


Spoiler
Show



Spoiler
Show


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fIE5GbS7...


by Dominic

ROUND 2 PICK:Sam, from CasablancaSam is Rick's best friend and confidant. He's followed Rick from Paris to Casablanca and will probably catch up with Rick once he settles in Brazzaville with Captain Renault. He tries not to play "As Time Goes By" for Elsa because broken-hearted Rick never wants to hear that song again, but who can resist Ingrid Bergman, amirite?Sam, played by D

Sam counts as a band? So then basically anyone who sings in any film counts, as long as they're fictional.


by chillrob

Sam counts as a band? So then basically anyone who sings in any film counts, as long as they're fictional.

Bands/Musicians, so Sam Counts.

Dom, you stole one of my next two picks. I was going to complete my tour of Dublin.

Sent from my Pixel 7a using Tapatalk


by BullyEyelash

Phat Mack, I assume you liked the outcast high school girl in Kill Bill?

GoGo? The girl from Battle Royale? Of course!


Mack, you need to put your last two picks on the spreadsheet


by chillrob

Sam counts as a band? So then basically anyone who sings in any film counts, as long as they're fictional.

Sam is a musician in the movie. So he counts. Someone like Julie Andrews in the Sound Of Music would not count. Any performance in a musical would not count UNLESS that character is a musician in the movie.


Round4

Mothera (1961)

portrayed by Pair Bambi Yuko and Yoko Okada

Always enchanting and always touch notch, the orchestration of the Vintage Kaiju genre was treated with reverence and respect... and I have respect and fondness thereof.

Lyrics:
Open your eyes, Mothra
Let the flowers bloom, Mothra.
They're all waiting for you
To the blue sky with your shining wings
Take flight, Mothra

Open your eyes, Mothra
Let the morning dawn, Mothra
They're waiting for you
Let the dew of your tears soon be gone from your cheeks.
Quickly, Mothra.

Open your eyes, Mothra.
Let the clouds sing, Mothra
They're waiting for you.
And in the endless darkness, hear their cries of prayer.
Hear us, Mothra.

R1- The Rubber Band
R2- Jan Pehechan ho
R3- Red Rocking Chair
R4- Mothera


Lol OMG the Mothra chicks.

Now that's a funny pick.


Round 4
Mitch and Mickey
- A Mighty Wind

Eugene Levy and Catherine OHara are fantastic as Mitch and Mickey This was a tough call as I was tempted to just take the entire cast of this movie as the whole thing is a fake bandapalooza. Not sure that would be within the rules? But I took M&M because Levy is at his comedic best in this role and cracks me up every time he is on screen.

Of course the creators of this movie are likely the best known "fake" band trio ever. Their initial fake band blew up so huge it it resulted in albums and tour dates. Definitely undraftable due to the Monkees rule 😀

so far:
Otis Day and the Knights
Sweet Sue and Her Society Syncopaters
The Barden Bellas
Mitch and Mickey

Reply...