Israel/Palestine thread
Think this merits its own thread...
Discuss my fellow 2+2ers..
AM YISRAEL CHAI.
[QUOTE=Crossnerd]Edit: RULES FOR THIS THREAD
Posting guidelines for Politics and Soci...
These are our baselines. We're not reinventing the wheel here. If you aren't sure if something is acceptable to post, its better to ask first. If you think someone is posting something that violates the above guidelines, please report it or PM me rather than responding in kind.
To reiterate some of the points:
1. No personal attacks. This is a broad instruction, but, in general, we want to focus on attacking an argument rather than the poster making it. It is fine to say a post is antisemitic; it is not okay to call someone an antisemite over and over. If you believe someone is making antisemitic posts, report them or PM me. The same goes for calling people "baby killers" and "genocide lovers". You are allowed to argue that an action supports genocide or that the consequences of certain policies results in the death of children, but we are no longer going to be speaking to one another's intentions. It is not productive to the conversation and doesn't further any debate.
2. Racist posts and other bigoted statements that target a particular group or individuals of such groups with derogatory comments are not allowed. This should not need further explanation.
3. Graphic Images need to be in spoilers with a trigger warning.
4. Wishing Harm on other posters will result in an immediate timeout.
5. Genocidal statements such as "Kill 'em all" etc, are no longer permissible in the thread.
If anyone has any questions about the above, please PM me. I don't want a discussion about the rules to derail the content of this thread. If anything needs clarifying, I will do that in this thread.
Please be aware this thread is strictly moderated[/quote]
why are you lying?
I'm shocked more countries aren't in favor of the Trump plan. Hate is not a profitable industry.
Well, it isn't economically profitable. But it does confer political capital. In Muslim majority countries distracting the people with Palestinian propaganda has, and continues to be, a very good vehicle for bad leaders to distract the populace from domestic failures.
So far Trump has stated plans to:
Annex Canada
Annex Greenland
Take back the Panama Canal
Tariffs on Venezuela, Mexico, Canada
--And none of these things is going to happen. So I am not sure why everyone is pretending like his Gaza plan is going to happen either.
So far Trump has stated plans to:
Annex Canada
Annex Greenland
Take back the Panama Canal
Tariffs on Venezuela, Mexico, Canada
--And none of these things is going to happen. So I am not sure why everyone is pretending like his Gaza plan is going to happen either.
many liberals, including in mainstream press, are pretending this bc they want to throw rhetorical gotchas at the people who criticized the Dems. its really low. esp when directed at the people who just watched their families get massacred.
I mean this guy has like 280k followers
So far Trump has stated plans to:
Annex Canada
Annex Greenland
Take back the Panama Canal
Tariffs on Venezuela, Mexico, Canada
--And none of these things is going to happen. So I am not sure why everyone is pretending like his Gaza plan is going to happen either.
It may surprise you to know that a President who literally says any garbage out loud, and consequently can't be taken at his word, is not a GOOD thing
yes my critiques are always substantive.
many liberals, including in mainstream press, are pretending this bc they want to throw rhetorical gotchas at the people who criticized the Dems. its really low. esp when directed at the people who just watched their families get massacred.
I mean this guy has like 280k followers
Oh man. The GLEE with which these libs are celebrating the further killing and displacement of Palestinians is so ****ing disgusting, both now AND right after the election. It's horrifying.
Also, these Democrats act like the small percentage of anti-Zionist voters who voted for Trump or Stein or whomever actually, like, changed the entire result of the election. Could it be something wrong with what WE are doing? Nahhhhh, let's punch down at random Arab-American voters, all while continuing to take their votes for granted.
Well we know cheap rhetorical gotchas at critics are something you're a consistent opponent of.
This is an award-winning "glass houses" post. Wow!
"the further killing and displacement of Palestinians"
I don't think a single person wants it, or believes it tbh. What power does Trump actually have here?
If Trump pulls some master coup involving the Saudis and the PA and we wind up with some kind of plan, then there's something to talk about.
In the meanwhile, all anyone is saying is "If you were Muslim and trusted this grifter, you may want to start re-evaluating how you pick a candidate"
And that's pretty darn fair. Dearborn just has to take the L here, along with anyone else who got grifted.
Hanania is a neo Nazi as well you know, considering you've linked his crap before. Nobody who isn't a neo Nazi cares what he burbles. Any point you attempt to make will automatically be null and void by virtue of the fact that you're linking neo Nazis to accentuate it. How you can't see this is quite stunning.
Thats because Dunyain is a white supremacist lol
He campaigned on America first and pulling out of war zones. I just don't see him suddenly using the army here. It doesn't make any sense (and certainly his base would freak).
If he sends 30k troops and a carrier group to take Gaza, I'll be the first to post here that I was wrong. But that'll start an epic Jihad too.
"the further killing and displacement of Palestinians"
I don't think a single person wants it, or believes it tbh. What power does Trump actually have here?
If Trump pulls some master coup involving the Saudis and the PA and we wind up with some kind of plan, then there's something to talk about.
In the meanwhile, all anyone is saying is "If you were Muslim and trusted this grifter, you may want to start re-evaluating how you pick a candidate"
And that's pretty darn fair. Dearborn just has to take t
ya most people didnt vote for either of the genocidal candidates
"the further killing and displacement of Palestinians"
I don't think a single person wants it, or believes it tbh.
Yikes! Well, spend 5 minutes on Twitter and you'll figure out the ludicrousness of that assertion.
What power does Trump actually have here?
If Trump pulls some master coup involving the Saudis and the PA and we wind up with some kind of plan, then there's something to talk about.
In the meanwhile, all anyone is saying is "If you were Muslim and trusted this grifter, you may want to start re-evaluating how you pick a candidate"
And that's pretty darn fair. Dearborn just has to take the L here, along with anyone else who got grifted.
I'm sure that a huge swath of the Dearborn and anti-Zionist voters elsewhere didn't hold any delusions that Trump (who famously moved the US embassy to Jerusalem in his first term) would be good for Palestinians in Gaza or anywhere else. They were engaging in what is known as a "protest vote". They were saying "the Democratic Party is a Zionist, imperialist party just like the Republicans, so we're gonna show them that unless they make legit changes in policy and action, they can't take our votes for granted any longer."
Whether that's a wise strategy or not can be debated, but this wasn't a case of anybody getting grifted.
And, by the way, the centrists and Dems have to take Trump's horrors just like the left does, so them punching down at these poor voters is obviously just them coping and seething, as they say.
Yikes! Well, spend 5 minutes on Twitter and you'll figure out the ludicrousness of that assertion.
I'm sure that a huge swath of the Dearborn and anti-Zionist voters elsewhere didn't hold any delusions that Trump (who famously moved the US embassy to Jerusalem in his first term) would be good for Palestinians in Gaza or anywhere else. They were engaging in what is known as a "protest vote". They were saying "the Democratic Party is a Zionist, imperialist party just like the Republicans, so w
Chickens can protest themselves all the way into the KFC man. Protest away.
They're going to know real soon who is the most pro-Israel party of the two.
This is a terrible idea. You never want to give the terrorists the high ground. How would this make things any better? No way these people should have a country bordering Israel on either side.
You're SPEAKING to a terrorist, bro. I mean that factually and literally. Terrorism, simply defined, is the use of violence against citizens for political purposeses. The IDF, of which Blue is an active (?) member, has been thoroughly confirmed to A. use violence, B. against citizens, and C. for a political purpose
That's so disgusting. Christ. You're practically edging at the thought of dead Palestinians.
They know NOW. LOL. You don't understand what these protest-voters were doing, even after it was patiently explained to you.
You still somehow think they were sitting there going "hurrr, Trump is gonna bring peace to the Middle East!" I get you're not a big fan of the Palestinian and Palestinian-American people, but surely you can still give them enough credit to not portray the entire group as 60 IQ subliterate rubes.
That's so disgusting. Christ. You're practically edging at the thought of dead Palestinians.
No, and you projecting that on me doesn't make it so.
I didn't want Trump in office because he's insane. I won't want him in power for as long as he holds it. And I hope MAGA collapses after this once in a few generation leader is gone.
But I knew damn well what he actually was, and what he convinced people he was. So we're focusing on the grift here, no matter how hard you want it to be the other way.
That's so disgusting. Christ. You're practically edging at the thought of dead Palestinians.
They know NOW. LOL. You don't understand what these protest-voters were doing, even after it was patiently explained to you.
You still somehow think they were sitting there going "hurrr, Trump is gonna bring peace to the Middle East!" I get you're not a big fan of the Palestinian and Palestinian-American people, but surely you can still give them enough credit to not portray the entire group as 60 I
is Trump even worse? at this point he has a lot of work to do to catch up to the Dems.
Karl for some context, so your blood pressure drops a few points, this same thing is happening in the Hispanic community in the USA. Same grift.
As Selena cries on social, everyone is starting to realize he was the worst possible vote for anyone with Central and South American heritage. Grifters gonna grift. And that voter segment was pretty damn big.
Transpose that sentiment here. Same same.