Survivor: GENERAL THREAD
I wanted to post something Survivor related but realized there's no general thread about Survivor. Each thread is about
Binged some Traitors after learning Rob C would be on and, while its a great concept, what horrible execution. Team competition with no stakes between teams, drawn out editing and repeated scenes in and out of commercial breaks (makes sense 20 years ago but not now), no incentive for Traitors to sabotage or subterfuge beyond the basics of concealing their identities, challenge
Have you tried the UK version? Host is great and she plays it seriously with very little camp. Also regular folks competing instead of pseudo-celebrities, which I always thought was the charm of Survivor.
UK season 1 is mostly people crying and saying "I'm a faithful", but season 2 is great, with some good gameplay on both the traitor and faithful sides and some entertaining characters. Definitely my fave so far (having watched all the English-speaking seasons).
agreed. traitors is absolute trash on basically every level. i dont know how people like it
agreed. traitors is absolute trash on basically every level. i dont know how people like it
One of my big issues is for the producers/traitors to convert a faithful way late in the game. Also, there seems to be a bit of production game manipulation.
The series is entertainment pretending to be a game. And it IS entertaining!
USA Traitors is by far the worst out of all the English Language versions i've seen (UK, Au, USA, Canada)
Having a bunch of people that already know each other completely breaks the game which is already pretty broken to begin with.
Now S50 is officially filmed thought I'd submit my very early pre season most likely to win power rankings
Contenders
1) Coach
2) Jenna Lewis
3) Rick Devons
4) Colby
5) Charlie
6) Aubry
7) Stephanie Lagrossa
8) Genevieve
9) Joe
10) Emily
Middle of the pack
11) Kamilla
12) Tiffany
13) Dee
14) Ozzy
15) Chrissy
Outside chance
16) Mike White
17) Kyle
18) Angelina
Cant see winning a jury vote if they get to the end
19) Q
20-21 Rizzo/Savannah
22) Jonathan
How on earth do you get to the end
23) Christian
24) Cirie
Survivor Australia v the World starts on Sunday
I'm 1/2 way through the last season. I'm always impressed how the Australian version just crushes the USA version.
Better challenges
Better twists
Better characters
Better drama
Only complaint may be that it feels like maybe more production interference during the game. i.e. they don't let things get too one-sided.
14 person cast and Parvati got 33% of all confessionals, more than the bottom 10 combined
Never change Australian Survivor
Episode 6 confessional update
Will put in spoilers in case anyone hasn't watched the episode yet
Spoiler
Parvati 50
Luke 28
Cirie 18
Shone 17
Janine 13
Lisa 9
Kass 8
Tommy 4
Parv with 16 more than the bottom half combined
Starting to get into Russell Hanz Samoa territory now
Episode 6 confessional update
Will put in spoilers in case anyone hasn't watched the episode yet
Spoiler
Parvati 50
Luke 28
Cirie 18
Shone 17
Janine 13
Lisa 9
Kass 8
Tommy 4
Parv with 16 more than the bottom half combined
Starting to get into Russell Hanz Samoa territory now
Spoiler
Yup at this point based on edit, hard to see Parv not taking this down.
Surprised Luke was that high, but him & Parv are the only ones that seem to be giving βgoodβ confessionals (sorry Cirie), though I cringed at the GoT/dragon analogy she tried to force.
Cirieβs βbamboozled, flummoxedβ line was fun, but I guess sheβs saving her material for tribal.
Episode 7 - not a spoiler - if you’re a contestant, why/how do you consent to having cameras in the shower?
Episode 7 - not a spoiler - if youβre a contestant, why/how do you consent to having cameras in the shower?
Also not a spoiler, but episode 7 was absolutely wild
You know you're in for a ride when tribal council starts with 40 minutes left of the episode
One contestant probably had the single worst episode of gameplay in Survivor history.
is there a youtube channel or somewhere i can watch this? all i was able to find was a channel that has all of S1 of survivor australia
Spoilers for AU vs the world season below;
Spoiler
Like most Australian Survivor seasons was largely entertaining, especially the first two weeks, but ultimately was let down by dreadful editing.
After literally episode 1 I had Parvati down as
-90% chance to win
-9% losing finalist/fallen angel
-1% finishing 5th-13th
Why they are so insistent on essentially spoiling their own show with extreme winner telegraphing is beyond me.
No way. Awesome
At this point if you aren't watching Australian Survivor, it's basically the equivalent of not watching the Champions League if you are a soccer fan.
agreed. traitors is absolute trash on basically every level. i dont know how people like it
It's way better with newbie players who aren't 'famous'. The reality stars on the US version just treat the show as a means to get more followers on insta so of course they are just gonna blow up their games for airtime. I think the US is finally doing a newbie version for 2026.
Now S50 is officially filmed thought I'd submit my very early pre season most likely to win power rankingsContenders1) Coach 2) Jenna Lewis3) Rick Devons4) Colby5) Charlie6) Aubry7) Stephanie Lagrossa8) Genevieve9) Joe10) EmilyMiddle of the pack11) Kamilla12) Tiffany13) Dee14) Ozzy15) ChrissyOutside chance16) Mike White17) Kyle18) AngelinaCant see winning a jury vote if they ge
I think the 49 people have slightly more chance that you think if they get to the end with people like Jonathan, Joe, Tiffany, Angelina who aren't really seen as great players and people like Steph an Ozzy who are awful people IRL. I suspect both of them will be better players than all those I mentioned. I also don't think Coach is a realistic contender anymore, he's gonna blow up his game trying to be a cult leader. That won't fly in the new era.
49 players will be interesting since they’ll know each other but no one else will have seen them play. I always enjoyed when they used to do players on back to back seasons.
I think the 49 people have slightly more chance that you think if they get to the end with people like Jonathan, Joe, Tiffany, Angelina who aren't really seen as great players and people like Steph an Ozzy who are awful people IRL. I suspect both of them will be better players than all those I mentioned. I also don't think Coach is a realistic contender anymore, he's gonna blow
I agree I do think at least one of the 49 players will go fairly deep in the season, however they are also such a default first boot candidate for a safe vote too.
My Coach at number 1 logic is I understand he does have quite a few 'new era' connections outside of the show and will potentially lean into the reliable elder statesman role. He's also never been overly strategic and is strong enough in team challenges so there's not too much value in targeting him in early.
I also think the jury might be looking for a 'legend of the game' to represent their season if one does get to the end
We're back! Come on in.